10/21/11

GOP would do nothing but cut taxes; Obama is taking action

Reasons to agree:
  1. E.J. Dionne. "GOP's Favorite Solution: Doing Nothing." Real Clear Politics. October 13th, 2011: "WASHINGTON -- So let’s see: The solution to large-scale abuses of the financial system, a breakdown of the private sector, extreme economic inequality and the failure of companies and individuals to invest and create jobs is -- well, to give even more money and power to very wealthy people, to disable government and to trust those who got us into the mess to get us out of it. ¶ That’s a brief summary of the news from the Republican Party this week. It’s what Republican candidates said during the Washington Post-Bloomberg debate, and it’s the signal Senate Republicans sent in voting as a bloc against President Obama’s jobs bill. Don’t just do something, stand there. ¶ Those who have plenty of capital to invest are holding back because consumers don’t have enough cash. But let's not give potential middle-class buyers jobs and money to spend. No, let's heap yet more resources onto investors. And if sharp guys made fortunes writing abusive mortgages, let’s repeal all the rules we just passed to prevent them from doing the same thing again. ¶ Better yet, don’t blame the people who got the windfalls. Blame poor people. Thus did Rep. Michele Bachmann place responsibility for the mortgage mess on the Community Reinvestment Act, a law aimed at preventing discrimination against people in neighborhoods, many of them predominantly African-American, where banks wouldn't make loans. The CRA had nothing to do with the proliferation of subprime mortgages; old-fashioned greed did the trick there. But it’s so much easier to pass the buck to the powerless. They don’t make many campaign contributions."
  2. Tax cuts aren't very stimulative because they get saved rather than spent.
Reasons to disagree:
  1.  Spending more money than we have is worse than doing nothing. 
  2. The USA should cut taxes
  3. Obama is campaigning for office. Republicans have plans. The democrats run the Senate, and Harry Read wouldn't bring Obama's Job plan to be voted on because he knew he didn't have the votes FROM DEMOCRATS!
Probable interest of those who agree:
  1. Anti black racism
  2. Confirmation bias (you decide that you don't like Obama, and so this becomes the prism that you see him. People always root for the home team, because over time they start to show interest, and then each new story tells them they were correct. When the other team acts badly, you get mad. When your team acts badly, you feel justified. You continue to identify with Obama, because you once did). 
  3. Your a Republican. He is on the other team. He is the enemy. 
Probable interest of those who disagree:
  1. Pro black racial preference
  2. Your a Democrat. He is on the same team, against the enemy

Common Interest

Opposing Interest
  1.  

Images That agree

  1.   
Images That disagree


      Videos That agree
      1.  
      Videos That disagree
      1.  

      Website that agree

      Websites that disagree
      1.  

      Related arguments:


        # of reasons to agree: 0
        # of reasons to disagree: -0
        # of reasons to agree with reasons to agree: 0
        # of reasons to agree with reasons to disagree: -0
        Total Idea Score: 0

        Don't like the score? It is easy to change the score. Just post a reason to agree or disagree with the overall idea, or any of the reasons and the score will change

        No comments: